Monday, April 7, 2008

Menschen Erleiden Geschichte by Leonard McCombe

Who the hell is Leonard McCombe? Did I miss a meeting? Oh, I now know the basics -- that he was a Life magazine photographer and that he once made a photograph of a cowboy that inspired the Marlboro Man advertisements, and I know he is a Manx from the Isle of Man, but my recent discovery of his book published in Germany called Menschen Erleiden Geschichte (Humans Suffering History) demands that I know more about this man who created this incredible document of World War II. At the risk of ruffling the delicate feathers of idolatry I consider this work of such high quality that in my opinion it easily deserves an equal seat alongside that of Robert Capa 'the world's greatest war photographer.'

Published in 1948 by Atlantis Verlag, Menschen Erleiden Geschichte is subtitled The Face of Europe from the Thames up to Weichsel 1943-1946 and contains 212 photographs by McCombe. This title has text and captioning by Bill Richardson but being that it was published in German the text escapes me. The overall tone of this book from what I can make out is one of the human costs of war regardless of whether the participants are on the side of the axis or allies.

McCombe's camera pays as much attention to the events as to the inner emotional state of the subjects. Much of what is striking about this work is McCombe's ability to work and yet go unnoticed at times when the subject seems to be experiencing deep inner reflection.

McCombe starts his journey in Normandy France in 1944 with what looks like the French troops pursuing retreating German forces. The first picture shows a young soldier through the window of the vehicle as he blankly stares ahead as if foreseeing the events he is about to witness. Within the next few photographs the troops come under fire, crawl through ditches, duck for cover behind burning tanks, and navigate their way past fallen bodies. The town is in rubble, the population is displaced and McCombe turns his attention away from the fighting and concentrates on the costs. He doesn't seem to be using a lens any longer than a 50 mm so most of the description is up close and personal, giving the viewer a sense of tension from danger.

Within the next chapter, German prisoners of war are rounded up and processed in the wounded are attended to. It is within the sequence that McCombe momentarily turns his attention to a field surgeon as he operates in a makeshift hospital room while outside the dead are being recorded and buried.

The next major sequence brings McCombe into London and amongst the populace as they try and absorb the cost of the blitz from a couple years prior and return to some semblance of routine. This sequence is rapidly cut short by renewed violence in a small chapter called New Triumphs in Science, New Form of Destruction which shows the aftermath of a German V-1 pilotless bomb attack. This new technology would go on to kill almost 9000 civilians in Britain. Here McCombe makes his way through the chaos of the crowds as medical teams and civilians assist to the wounded.

After VE Day, McCombe made his way into Berlin in 1946 and a chapter called Down for a Long Time opens with a photograph taken at the train station as hundreds of homeless civilians crowd onto the roofs of the train cars. Again, McCombe's gaze is nonjudgmental even towards those in uniform. His camera connects with the universal humanity that bridges across nationality or politics.

The last chapter of Menschen Erleiden Geschichte as the book's subtitle suggests starts with us flying over Western Poland in 1946 before dropping to the devastation on the ground. The reconstruction effort seems pointless as everything is reduced to rubble. McCombe brings the book to a close with a short sequence of a makeshift encampment of Poles that are able to salvage little from what was left. The caption underneath reads as somewhat melodramatic; Rubble, tears and death -- that is the harvest of war.

As with many books that protest war, this one probably has its fair share of heavy-handed and cliché captioning (luckily for me I don't understand German to have that be a detractor) but the photography is exceptional. It is not just McCombe's humanism at work but the impression that he is everywhere at once and filling up his frames with a complexity that is rarely seen while a photographer is under such duress.

The book is beautifully printed in gravure and the design makes use of many exciting cross-page spreads and sequences. Small sections of Richardson's texts break up the photographs into sections and a running commentary underneath the images, accent the individual photographs.

McCombe has a few other books; Navajo Means People, The Cowboy, and You Are My Love and although each feature some fine work, this book is the most complete and shining example of his talent. W. Eugene Smith in an essay on photojournalism mentions Henri Cartier-Bresson and Leonard McCombe as two examples of 35mm "natural light" photographers, so obviously his work was well respected amongst his peers. With that in mind, I ask again, who the hell is Leonard McCombe? And why is it so hard to find any substantial information about this remarkable photographer?

A special thank you to Ed Grazda for the scan of the dustjacket.


Cary Conover said...

About four years ago I came across a book that was a compilation of classic Life photo essays. McCombe's "Career Girl" is in it and it's amazing.

Anonymous said...

From Gordon Parks' recollections, as collected by John Leonard in "LIFE Photographers: What They Saw":

"I found a lot of emotion in [W. Eugene Smith]'s work. More so than I did in most of the other photographers. Other photographers would come up with something now and then, but if you saw a story of Gene's, you expected it to be packed with emotion. Leonard McCombe had a good style with a certain chord. You know what I mean? A touch. I think Leonard could have been a good fashion photographer if he'd applied himself."

I can't help thinking it sounds like a back-handed compliment. But maybe that's just because I'm not a fan of fashion photography.

Anonymous said...

Actually, the editor of the LIFE photographers volume is John Loengard. Sorry for the mix-up.

Anonymous said...


That sounds very back-handed but keep in mind, I don't know if I've seen a Gordon Parks photo that I think is interesting much after a second or third viewing.

Thanks for that. Did you know who McCombe is/was? Is he still with us? I want to talk to him.

Unknown said...

McCombe was very much a force at LIFE during the postwar period, but he simply never got the prestige accolades that Smith & HCB drew in. I suspect he probably had more bylines on LIFE than anyone else during the 50's, and as far as I know he's still around -- he'd be 85 now.

Anonymous said...

Jeff, I have asked a friend, a former Life editor, for contact info for McCombe. I have pasted below the info that is available on the George Eastman House database. It seems he is still among us as the obituary search I ran turned up nothing. It appears that some of his pictures are distributed by Getty Images so you might try them for contact info.
In addition to the Time-Life volume listed below there are also two pages that include a portrait of him with six of his pictures in: Rayfield, Stanley. Life Photographers: Their Careers and Favorite Pictures. NY: Doubleday, 1957, pp. 56-57.

BIOGRAPHY -------------------------------
MAKER: McCombe, Leonard ACTIVE: 1939-1972


DATE/PLACE OF BIRTH: Isle of Man, Douglas


--Photojournalism.-- Life Library of Photography, New York: 1971.

An emigrant to the U.S., 1945, McCombe became a naturalized citizen in
1953. He retired from photography with the demise of the original
--Life,-- magazine, 1972.

photographer, photojournalist

------------------- EXHIBITS CHRONOLOGY FOR McCombe, Leonard -------------------

1 1947.10.01 Three Young Photographers: Leonard McComb, Wayne Miller, Homer
Museum of Modern Art B
2 1951.11.21 Memorable Life Photographs
Museum of Modern Art - Audito Steichen, Edward B
3 1955.01.24 Family of Man
Museum of Modern Art Steichen, Edward B
4 1959.05.08 Photography In The Fine Arts - An Exhibition of Great Contempor
Metropolitan Museum of Art Rorimer, James J. B
5 1959.11.09 Photography At Mid-Century: 10th Anniversary Exhibition
GEH - Chappell, Walter BG
6 1961.06.14 Photography In The Fine Arts - III
Minneapolis Institute of Arts Rorimer, James J. B
7 1976.07.23 Remarkable American Women
8 1979 Life: The First Decade 1936-1945
Grey Art Gallery Littman, Robert R. B

--------------------- MODEST holdings except * (MAJOR) ---------------------
1 *NY New York Time Inc. Picture Collection
2 CA Los Angeles Los Angeles County Museum of Art
3 FL St. Petersburg Museum of Fine Arts (St. Petersburg, FL)
4 NY New York International Center of Photography
5 NY New York Metropolitan Museum of Art (Dept. of Photographs)
6 NY New York Museum of Modern Art
7 NY Rochester George Eastman House

Karin Photogoddess said...


Just read this article & am stunned since I've been trying to find this book forever. Where is it available??

Please contact me with any info where I might locate it or if you are interested in selling.

I'm reachable at:

Hope someone who can help reads this. Thanks much. PG

Hernan Zenteno said...

After three years, did you get some info? For several years I wanted to know more o Mr. McCombe. The most well known essays he did are the one you mentioned in your article and Career Girl that was commented here. But I am curious about lot of more work he did. I saw that he did a lot of photos In Argentine, the country I live, and he covered JFK, Sammy Davis Jr, the effects of this 60´s drug to avoid conception, and a lot of good work. But I miss some archive online that mention some more about that and to see some of his photos. The Life archives can be of some help but the photos are all mixed. Anyway, thanks for share some of this book.